Comparative Study Narration / Film 1: The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari/Film 2: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
Comparative Study Narration
Film 1: The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari
Film 2: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
Thesis Statement
My area of film focus is the film movement, German expressionism. The topic is the influence of
German Expressionism and the classification of Robert Weine’s The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari
(1920) and Time Burton’s Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007) into the
stylistic conventions of the movement.
Justification
Films influenced by and classified under German Expressionism have a classical style of
distorting reality, having gothic storylines, abstract set designs, using stylistic makeup and
other visual filmic elements to portray human emotions in a raw form. German expressionism
has been immensely successful in influencing different genres as well as movements in film and
has had an extremely valuable impact on cinema. The French New Wave, Noir and Neo –
Noir and the horror genre have evident adaptations from the movement.
Due to its highly visual, surrealistic and formalistic nature, and the ambiguous interpretation
of meaning created by those elements, German Expressionism gives a huge scope of
discussion and comparison.
The two chosen films come from a huge time- period- difference of 87 years that will allow
me to talk about classification of the two films into German Expressionism and the influence of
the movement on modern day films. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari is one of the first defining
films of German Expressionism which was geographically based and shot in Germany with the
symbolic portrayal of political situation as well as the mental state of the people at that time.
Sweeney Todd, a film which was highly influenced by the movement, on the other hand, was
based and shot in London in 2007 but portrayed the socio – political and economic cultural
context of the 18th
- 19th Century Victorian Era, the time period in which the story was set. This
contrast in the time periods as well as geographical contexts give a good scope of comparison
between the film along with their classification into the movement of German Expressionism.
Realism, Classicism and Formalism
Formalist films are often identified by their extreme use of visual elements like absurd sets,
heavily stylistic makeup and costumes, emotional plot lines, unpredictable and uncommon
camera angles and magnifications. They are far from portraying reality and focus on creation
of mood and portrayal of uninhibited emotions.
Realist films on the other hand focus on portraying reality as it is with the use of nonprofessional actors, long shots, simple and natural sets and stories that generally conveyed the
real-life struggles and stories of people.
Classicist films, which lie in the middle of the scale, have a good sense of reality in the plots,
but at the same time make use of visual and formalistic components to bring out the themes,
mood and tone of the films.
In this overarching scale of Formalism to Realism, the film movement of German Expressionism
as well as the two chosen films evidently fall under formalism.
Introduction to the Film
Focus
German expressionism can accurately be defined as “The rejection of western conventions,
and the depiction of reality symbolically that is widely distorted for an emotional effect.”
(Darsa,2013)
After their severe defeat in World War 1, Germans were left in a state of depression, distrust
and they were psychologically scarred by the horrors of the war. All the western films were
banned in Germany, which led to the creation of the moment. (Mensing, 2019) The filmmakers
then turned to expressionism which was raw emotional evocation.
The major purpose of Cinema in the early 1900s was to capture and portray common life just
the way it was, but German expressionistic film makes took a very steep turn from that and
created something which was extremely far away from reality, rather an “expression” of the
emotional and mental state of the country at that time. (100 years of cinema, 2016)
Some of its characteristics are the use of chiaroscuro lighting, dramatic shadows, expressive
and distorted set designs, heavy use of makeup, and extreme camera angles. The usual mood
and plot lines of these films are dark, gothic and horrific which create a thrilling and unsettling
effect on the audience.
Some of the most iconic films of the movement apart from The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari are
Nosferatu (1922), Metropolis (1927) and M (1931).
Comparatively, some of the Modern era films influenced by German Expressionism along with
Sweeney Todd are Edward Scissorhands (1990), Dark Shadows (2012) and Labyrinth (2006).
PLOT
Film 1: The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari
Film 2: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
Film 2: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
Film 2: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
Sweeney Todd first appeared in literature in the mid - nineteenth century, which, uncertainly
was inspired from an actual murderer in the 1700s. It became a penny dreadful in the early
20th Century, which was then adapted into a Broadway musical. Tim Burton, adapted the story
from the musical. It is the story of a barber, Sweeney Todd who returns to seek revenge. He
partners up with Mrs. Lovett in a horrifying act, where with his barber’s knife he slits people’s
throat and Mrs. Lovett then uses that meat from the victims to make meat pies. Although it was
released in 2007, it is based in the Victorian Era in London (19th Century), and has made
successful symbolic cultural connections with the social and economic cultural context of the
time period from where the original story has been adapted from.
Direction: (mise en scene - set design, props, costume and makeup)
Film 1
The director has made a very heavy use of the mise en scene elements to create the mood
of the film.
The painted background set design contains extremely absurd designs, like, uneven and non -
parallel building structure, twisted and spread branches, and roads that don’t lead anywhere.
With the help of this kind of expressionistic feature a very distorted image of reality is being
created, which is one of the classical characteristics of German Expressionism. This is symbolic
of the sense of confusion and distortion that Germany was in post WW1 and the state of a
schizophrenic and insane mind that is created in totalitarianism and dictatorship.
Whenever we see any government officials in the film, i.e., the town clerks and the police
officers, they are sitting on unusually high chairs. It creates a very obvious symbol of the
power and authority that the government held, and were literally placed higher than the
common people. Such use of props to symbolize the real-life political situation is another
defining characteristics of German expressionism. The staircase that led to the police
authorities in the film were painted in a way, that one couldn’t tell the direction by looking at
it. It shows how unclear and doubtful the connection between the government and the common
people had become, also symbolizing distrust. (Why It’s Great, 2020)
The introduction to Cesare felt like an introduction to the living dead, especially because of
makeup technique of enhancing the dark circles around the eyes, which added to the
mysterious, creepy and nightmarish effect created by the set design. Cesare, was under the
complete control of Caligari. This showed how the government manipulated the people, and
killed their spirits, making them dead inside. It is also symbolic of how the young were sent to
kill and die in the German trenches, against their active will.
Film 2
A similar use of mise en scene elements can be seen in this film.
Sweeney Todd’s appearance is also like that of a walking corpse, i.e., due to the makeup
and enhancement of the dark circles, similar to Cesare. Because of the hardships in his life, he
had become hopeless and was seeking for ruthless vengeance. This is a feature of German
expressionism as well as a symbol of oppression of the poor in the Victorian era due to the
industrial revolution which led to hopelessness and death.
The set design of this film, however, is not as absurd and distorted as film 1. This creative
choice is coherent as well as ironic to the film movement at the same time because German
expressionist films were known for distorting the set designs. In this film the said design is very
much a reflection of the Victorian era but at the same time elements of German expressionistic
non-parallel and twisted structures can be seen. It has been successful in slightly exaggerating
the plight of the poor by showing rats, dirt, smoke and filth in the introduction of the town.
We see the use of reflective surfaces as props quite a few times in the film. For example,
Todd’s knife, the shattered mirror, the pool of water and the glass window. This shows the
state of agitation and introspection that Sweeney Todd was in, as he tried to devise a plan
for his vengeance. His agitated emotional facial expressions also show the fight that he was
fighting with himself, hence the significance of mirror-like surfaces.
Todd’s state of mind is reflective of the state of mind of the lower class in the 18th century
London. Due to the Industrial Revolution and classism, the poor were getting poorer. They were
in a state of self-reflection as well, and were struggling to fight their battle against poverty. A
similar use of symbolic props like these is clearly seen in film 1 and is a characteristic of
German expressionism.
We can see a difference between the costumes of Mrs. Lovett and Joanna, as Mrs. Lovett was
a struggling lower-class member of the society whereas Joanna, although captive, was under
the care of the upper-class member, Judge Turpin. The costumes in the film have adhered to
the social background of the 19th century London, for example, tight corsets and hoop skirts
for women, and long coats and layered shirts, for men.
(Comparison statement) Whereas Film 1 took a completely surrealistic approach, film 2 has
some slight elements of realism for the portrayal of the period it is set in. We can see
similarities and differences in the choices of the set design, makeup and props.
Editing: (pace, visual effects and color)
Film 1
There was a use of Vignette technique of editing, where the border of the frame is darkened
to lay emphasis on the subject of the frame. This technique enhanced the effectiveness of close
ups, making the connection with the emotions on the facial expressions of actors, and the
audience, deeper. The transitions between flashbacks are also related to this technique where
the entire frame blacks out from the border to center and then center to border, portraying
flashbacks, the story in the past that Francis narrated. Vignette was not as prominent in the
German expressionistic films as it was used in the cabinet of Dr. Caligari, but we do see some
films of the movement using that technique.
Talking about color, the filmmaker dyed the films yellow, to show daytime, blue, to show
darkness and pink, to show a location change, i.e., Jane’s House. It was considered as one of
the most brilliant techniques of that time, considering the technological advancements of the
time period it was shot in. This created a better understanding of the timings as it was shot a
black and white film. This technique is not something commonly present in German Expressionist
films, which are usually just black and white and not dyed.
The pace of the edit starts at a slow rate and then moves on to build up tension and suspense,
especially in the last acts of the film. German Expressionist films usually do have a slow edit
pace. However, in some scenes like, the murder of Alan and kidnapping of Jane, the music
and narrative has been successful in building up tension, without the help of fast pace editing.
This rather unpredictable pace of the film could be a portrayal of the unpredictability of the
government of Germany.
One of the first occurrence of visual effects in films was seen when the director’s mental state
was being portrayed by the text – “You must become Caligari” written on the frames, which
created an unsettling effect, showing the mental state of Dr. Caligari, clearly portraying
German expressionism, i.e., the use of unnaturalistic, formalistic and visual elements to create
mood, meaning and emotion.
Film 2
However, there was a dramatic improvement in the technology and the technological
advancement, the edits had now become easy to make, so, the pace and the alignment could
be changed within seconds. The smooth cuts in the film were also responsible in creating a very
well- ordered narrative.
Similar to Film 1, we can see the film follow a slow-paced editing in the start with longer cuts,
but still manages to build us the intensity and tension of some respective scenes with the help
of blocking. The edit follows the pace of the music and when it builds us, the edits become fast
paced as well. This difference in the pace is symbolic of how the industrial revolution, changed
the pace of the lives of the people in London and how that tensive state was like a
rollercoaster to them.
In contrast to film 1, flashbacks and different timelines in the film are portrayed using a
different technique. The color of the entire frame of the film mutes and unmutes laying a very
huge emphasis on the mood and symbols created in the film. Only the color red, is extremely
vibrant in all frames, creating a disturbing image. In majority of the film, the color is muted,
giving it a very ghoulish appearance. Even in the daytime, we can only see darkness, and less
exposed frames, which becomes a portrayal of the Great Smoke that was prevalent in the
city, due to the Industrial revolution. It is also a reflection of the gothic and dreadful theme of
the film. However, in the scenes where Todd narrates the past, i.e., when everything was
merry as well as the scene where Mrs. Lovett imagines a future with Mr. Todd, there is a very
vibrant use of color symbolizing hope and happiness.
Comparing with film 1, we can see a greater advancement in the use of visual effects in this
film. At the start of the film, where the crew and the cast is introduced, the name of the
members are shown on the frame in red, however, it does not hold the same significance that
the visual effects on film 1 hold.
(Comparison statement)
The directors have been successful in incorporating the classic
German expressionistic editing, and have also established a similar theme, with the help of
different techniques. The development of technology can be clearly seen when contrasting the
two films.
Cinematography: (lighting, movements and angles)
Film1
When both, Dr. Caligari and Cesare are introduced to the films, they break the fourth wall,
and look right into the camera, i.e., into the eyes of the audience, which successfully creates a
heightened unsettling effect.
The use of chiaroscuro lighting can be seen evidently, which has been successful in setting the
tone of the film. Chiaroscuro is a very popular technique of lighting in the German
expressionistic films. One of the most famous scenes in the history of cinema, i.e., the murder of
Alan, that was portrayed only with the use of enhanced dramatic shadows in a mid-shot, is
one of the classic features of German Expressionism. The shadows are also symbolic of the
shadowed state of mind that the people of Germany were forced to live in, due to the
totalitarian government. Incongruent shadows and dramatic lighting, maintained throughout, is
also used to show distance from trust and suspicion.
The film does not make use of unpredictable camera angles like the Dutch angle, and majorly,
we see parallel angled shots. This is incoherent with German Expressionism, as the movement is
famously known for the different, unique angles and non-parallel frames. However, taking in
consideration the technological context of the time, cinema was still in its initial stages and
filmmakers were still understanding the dynamics of shooting and motion picture. Mostly, all of
the shots in the film are static shots.
For example, in contrast to film 2, the establishing shot of the town is a static shot. However,
one of the first movement shots in the history of filmmaking can be seen in this film, i.e., when
Francis and the other doctors in the asylum are looking at Dr. Caligari’s books.
The magnifications throughout the film are usually long shots and mid shots. However, we do
see a use of close ups, a feature of German expressionism and the close-ups create an uneasy
effect, bringing us closer to the subject establishing a deeper connection to the story. Close ups
were prominent in German expressionism for the purpose to bring people closer to the
emotional state and tell the audience how personal and intimately the people of Germany
were affected.
Film2
Throughout the film, Sweeney Todd’s face is never completely exposed. We always look at
him in lowkey lighting (except for when he is Benjamin Barker) and the stark shadows are
always present on his face. This chiaroscuro lighting technique is very commonly seen in
German expressionistic films. The sharp shadows could be symbolic of the sharp difference
between the rich and poor in, it could also be a portrayal of the mental state, where the
lower-class members of the society were trying to find the middle ground between the
shadows and highlights, with respect to their morals. The use of silhouettes with dramatic
shadows and low-key lighting is maintained, portraying the overarching themes of the plot
effectively, and giving a gothic effect to the film which fits the plot very well.
Comparing to film 1, the establishing shot incorporates extreme camera movement with swish
and slow alternate movements that establish the setting of the entire town in the film. This
movement was important as well as extremely creative, as the audience gets a context to the
state of London, with respect to the filth, darkness, and poverty.
Unlike film 1, we see a use of different camera angles, including Dutch, making it a
representation of German expressionism. The contrasting high and low angles aligned
together signify the perspective of the poor and rich, creating a dynamic of power shift. It
also signifies the imbalance that was created in the city due to the Industrial Revolution and
how it was filled with Corruption.
The movements of the camera are rhythmic, and that makes the film aesthetically pleasing as
the movements follow the rhythm of the music.
We see a variety of different magnification, mainly composing of close ups, which is similar to
film 1. This is again, to form a deeper connection between the audience and the character.
(Comparison statement)
There is a similarity in the lighting and shadows but we can see a
significant difference when it comes to the camera angles and camera movements, but that is
hugely because of the difference in the time period of the production of both the films.
Summation and Conclusion
Although both films show significant number of similarities in terms of mise en scene, mood,
themes and shadows, both also have a remarkable number of contrasts, which portray the
difference in the time periods and well as cultural backgrounds. The directors have brought
out their own individual styles while keeping the connection with German Expressionism intact.
Both of the films can be classified into films under the German expressionism movement as well
as modern film influenced by it as we can see clear heavy influence of the movement by
pointing out the characteristics.
Citations:
• Ancestry Team. "What Was It Like To Live In 18Th-Century England? - Ancestry
Blog". Ancestry Blog, 2015, https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/what-was-it-like-to-live-in18th-century-england/. Accessed 7 Ju
• Britannica. "United Kingdom - British Society By The Mid-18Th Century". Encyclopedia
Britannica, 2013, https://www.britannica.com/place/United-Kingdom/British-societyby-the-mid-18th-century. Accessed 13 June 2021.
• Cook, Beverley, and Alex Werner. "Air Pollution, The Great Stink & The Great Smog |
Museum Of London". Museum Of London, 2017,
https://www.museumoflondon.org.uk/discover/londons-past-air. Accessed 13 Sept
2021
• Jackson, Lee. "'Dirty Old London': A History Of The Victorians' Infamous Filth". Npr.Org,
2015, https://www.npr.org/2015/03/12/392332431/dirty-old-london-a-history-ofthe-victorians-infamous-filth\. Accessed 10 June 2021.
• Katie. "Sweeney Todd, A Bloody Good Time!". Portland Center Stage At The Armory,
2012, https://www.pcs.org/archive/blog/item/sweeney-todd-a-bloody-good-time/.
Accessed 16 June 2021
• No Film School. "Video Essay: German Expressionism, Explained". Youtube.Com, 2016,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecuQdkBx1ic. Accessed 8 June 2021.
• PB Works. "The Significance Of Setting And Time Period In Sweeney Todd". PB, 2010,
http://3296sweeneytodd.pbworks.com/w/page/32357432/The%20Significance%2
0of%20Setting%20and%20Time%20Period%20in%20Sweeney%20Todd. Accessed
12 June 2021.
• Suer, Kinsley. "The Real Sweeney Todd? From Penny Dreadful To Broadway
Musical". Portland Center Stage At The Armory, 2012,
https://www.pcs.org/archive/blog/item/the-real-sweeney-todd-from-pennydreadful-to-broadway-musical. Accessed 4 June 2021.
• Wikipedia. "Penny Dreadful - Wikipedia". En.Wikipedia.Org,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_dreadful. Accessed 15 June 2021.
• Wikipedia. "Penny Dreadful - Wikipedia". En.Wikipedia.Org, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_dreadful. Accessed 15 June 2021.
• 100 years of Cinema. "1920: How The Cabinet Of Dr Caligari (1920) Was The First
Psychological Horror.". Youtube.Com, 2016, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIxD47Mp_A. Accessed 12 June 2021.
• HistoryExtra. "Victorian London’S East End: What Can A Foul Murder Tell Us About Life
In The City?". Historyextra, 2018, https://www.historyextra.com/period/victorian/lifevictorian-london-east-end-crime-poverty-slum-danger/. Accessed 13 June 2021.
• Fongpuisan. "German Expressionism". Film-Studies-3014.Blogspot.Com, 2012,
http://film-studies3014.blogspot.com/2012/#:~:text=Tim%20Burton%20was%20influenced%20by,%
22silent%20film%20with%20music%22.&text=The%20theme%20of%20self%2Danal
ysis,found%20in%20German%20expressionism%20film. Accessed 14 June 2021.
• French, Philip. "Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber Of Fleet Street". The Guardian,
2008, https://www.theguardian.com/film/2008/jan/27/johnnydepp.musical.
Accessed 12 June 2021.
• Film Theory. "German Expressionism - Film Theory". Film Theory, 2014,
https://www.filmtheory.org/german-expressionism/. Accessed 10 June 2021.
• Sofia, Ana. "Scenography In The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari". Unknownreel, 2018,
https://unknownreel.home.blog/2018/09/04/scenography-in-the-cabinet-of-drcaligari/. Accessed 18 June 2021.
• Youtube. "Tim Burton's Relationship With German Expressionism". Youtube.Com, 2021,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hv_7y0Yc8xE&list=TLPQMjQwNDIwMjHj_91cb29
LdQ&index=16. Accessed 16 June 2021.
• "What Is German Expressionism? A Beginner's Guide — Movements In
Film". Movements In Film, https://www.movementsinfilm.com/german-expressionism.
Accessed 14 June 2021.
• Movies, PDflix. "The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari (1920)". Youtube.Com, 2019,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gpn49rUuOGU&t=3801s. Accessed 6 June
2021.
• Yamout, Dania. "The Influence Of German Expressionist Cinema On The Films Of Tim
Burton". Medium, 2018, https://medium.com/@DaniaAtHome/the-influence-ofgerman-expressionist-cinema-on-the-films-of-tim-burton7e660e36f583#:~:text=Other%20films%20heavily%20influenced%20by,No%20Fil
m%20School%2C%202016. Accessed 7 June 2021


Comments
Post a Comment